Different design decisions with if-else-statements

Which of the following would you prefer:

    SomeEnum enum = SomeEnum.SOMETHING;
    if (aString.equals(anotherString)) {
        enum = SomeEnum.SOMETHING_ELSE;
    }
    return foo.bar(enum);

or

    if (aString.equals(anotherString)) {
        return foo.bar(SomeEnum.SOMETHING_ELSE);
    }
    return foo.bar(SomeEnum.SOMETHING);

I think I would prefer the first one, because it only has 1 point of return. On the other side I think that the second one is easier to read. What do you think? Maybe you got an even more sophisticated solution.