Why does this one chunk of code come up with error but the other one doesn't?

I have two sections of Python code - one works and the other one comes up with an error. What rule makes this the case?

Here is the chunk of code that got the error, along with the error:

Code:

elif door == "2": 
    print "You stare into the endless abyss at Cthulhu's retina."
    print "1. blueberries."
    print "2. Yellow jacket clothespins."
    print "3. Understanding revolvers yelling melodies."

    insanity = raw_input("> ")

    if insanity == "1" or insanity == "2": 
        print "Your body survives powered by a mind of jello. Good job!" 
        print "Now what will you do with the jello?"
        print "1. Eat it."
        print "2. Take it out and load it in a gun."
        print "3 Nothing."

        jello = raw_input("> ")

        if jello == "1" or jello == "2":
            print "Your mind is powered by it remember? Now you are   dead!"
        elif jello == "3":
            print "Smart move. You will survive." 
        else:
            print "Do something!" 

else: 
    print "The insanity rots your eyes into a pool of muck. Good job!"

I got this error message in prompt:

  File "ex31.py", line 29
  print "Now what will you do with the jello?"
                                           ^
IndentationError: unindent does not match any outer indentation level

BUT when my code is like this:

elif door == "2": 
print "You stare into the endless abyss at Cthulhu's retina."
print "1. blueberries."
print "2. Yellow jacket clothespins."
print "3. Understanding revolvers yelling melodies."

insanity = raw_input("> ")

if insanity == "1" or insanity == "2": 
    print "Your body survives powered by a mind of jello. Good job!" 
        print "Now what will you do with the jello?"
        print "1. Eat it."
        print "2. Take it out and load it in a gun."
        print "3 Nothing."

        jello = raw_input("> ")

        if jello == "1" or jello == "2":
            print "Your mind is powered by it remember? Now you are dead!"
        elif jello == "3":
            print "Smart move. You will survive." 
        else:
            print "Do something!" 

else: 
    print "The insanity rots your eyes into a pool of muck. Good job!"

I get no error message.

Basically my question is - why do I not get an error message if I indent the line

print "Now what will you do with the jello?"

...and the rest of the block of code below it.

But I get an error code if I leave it with the same indentation as the line above it?

Does this mean that the print line after an if statement can only be one line in total, with no other print lines allowed to be linked to the output of the if statement above the first print line of that block?

Thanks.